Nonprofit Leadership

When the Mission Depends on You

What nonprofit leaders revealed about the hidden cost of carrying too much — and what it takes to build an organization that can carry the mission with you.

Aretha Simons7 min read

Before the State of the Nonprofit Community Summit, I asked nonprofit leaders a few questions.

Not the usual questions about mission statements, budgets, or strategic plans.

I wanted to know what was really happening inside their organizations.

What funding situation keeps you up at night?

When your board meets, are they governing — or being briefed?

Who knows so much about how your organization operates that, if they walked away tomorrow, things might stop?

And perhaps the most revealing question: What is the conversation about your organization you have been avoiding?

We invited 100 nonprofit leaders and stakeholders to participate in our diagnostic, and 37 responded. Their answers weren't meant to represent the entire nonprofit sector. They were meant to help us listen — and they did. Behind those responses were real organizations wrestling with funding, governance, leadership, technology, and sustainability.

The goal was to ask the right questions and pay close attention to the answers.

And beneath many of those answers was the same tension: The mission is strong. But too often, too much of the mission is resting on too few people.

What We Learned

The responses pointed to four challenges that appeared again and again: funding pressure, boards that may not be fully sharing the responsibility of governance, organizations that depend heavily on one or two people, and very different levels of readiness for using AI and other time-saving tools.

But the numbers only told part of the story.

The words told us the rest.

The Funding Question Beneath the Funding Question

When we asked what funding situation kept people up at night, the answers were remarkably different.

One organization had lost its largest long-term funder. Another was relying on personal money to keep operating. Others were searching continuously for grants, trying to increase memberships, worrying about bills, or wondering how to pay an executive director.

We often hear nonprofits say, "We need more funding." Of course they do. But "more funding" is not a strategy.

The better question may be: What kind of funding does this organization need to become sustainable?

For one organization, the answer may be grants. For another, recurring donors. For another, earned income, sponsorships, memberships, government contracts, or a more diversified combination.

Before searching for the next grant opportunity, an organization may need to understand what it is actually trying to fund — and whether it has the infrastructure to manage that funding once it arrives.

When the Board Is Present — but the Founder Is Still Carrying the Organization

The board responses caught my attention.

Some respondents described boards actively discussing budgets, reserves, programs, and future challenges. Others described meetings centered primarily around reports, updates, and votes.

One response was especially simple: "I create the agenda. They vote."

There is a difference between having board members and having a governing board.

And that difference matters because capacity is not simply about hiring more people. Sometimes capacity means more people understanding the responsibility they already have.

What decision could your board help examine before it is presented for a vote? What relationship could a board member help cultivate? What responsibility is sitting with the founder or executive director simply because everyone has become accustomed to that person carrying it?

When the Organization Lives Inside One Person

Then we asked who knew the most about how the organization worked.

Several responses essentially said: Me.

Others named the founder, executive director, or CEO. Some organizations had documented their processes but still lacked enough trained people to carry them out. Succession planning even appeared among the conversations respondents said needed to happen.

This may be one of the most important capacity questions a nonprofit can ask: If the person who knows everything disappeared tomorrow, what would nobody else know how to do?

The goal is to protect the mission. Document one process. Train one additional person. Share one responsibility.

Capacity doesn't always begin with a new employee. Sometimes it begins with making sure critical knowledge no longer lives in one person's head.

AI Is Another Capacity Conversation

Thirty-five respondents answered our question about AI and time-saving tools. Ten said they were already using AI and seeing results. Eleven were experimenting. Five were aware of it but had not started, while nine said they weren't sure where to begin.

That tells me something important. Nonprofits do not need another message telling them that they are "behind." They need practical starting points.

Choose one repetitive task. Drafting an email. Creating a meeting agenda. Summarizing information. Documenting a process. Start there.

Technology should not replace the judgment, relationships, or humanity that make nonprofit work possible. It should create capacity for people to spend more time doing the work that requires those things.

The Question We Should Keep Asking

At the Summit, we didn't gather because we believed we had every answer. We gathered because nonprofit leaders need places where they can ask better questions.

Our diagnostic showed people at very different stages — from those still trying to establish an organization to leaders of established nonprofits wrestling with funding, governance, sustainability, infrastructure, and succession.

And that is why the conversation continues.

On January 23, 2027, the State of the Nonprofit Community Virtual Summit will gather again around another question: Are You Grant Ready?

We will look beyond simply finding grants to examine what organizations need in place to pursue funding responsibly — including grant writing, IRS requirements, state compliance, and organizational readiness.

Because sometimes the question is not: "Where can I find a grant?" The question beneath the question is: "Are we building an organization that is ready for the opportunity when it comes?"

And maybe that is the larger lesson our nonprofit diagnostic revealed. Passion starts organizations. But systems, people, governance, technology, funding strategy, and shared responsibility help them endure.

The mission may begin with you. It was never meant to depend entirely on you.

What would your organization's answers reveal? Take the State of the Nonprofit Community Diagnostic and use the questions to start a conversation with your board and leadership team.

nonprofit leadershipboard governanceorganizational capacitysustainabilityAI tools

About the Author

Aretha Simons

President, State of the Nonprofit Community, Inc.

Aretha Simons has spent more than two decades equipping nonprofit leaders across the Southeast with the tools, connections, and confidence to lead with clarity. As founder of the State of the Nonprofit Community, she has convened thousands of nonprofit professionals and guided organizations through the full arc of growth — from startup to sustainability.

Write for Us

Have Insights to Share?

We welcome original submissions from nonprofit leaders, consultants, attorneys, CPAs, and researchers.

Submit an Article
State of the Nonprofit Community Summit

Ideas. Resources. Connections.

Navigation

Contact

contact@stateofnp.org

Orlando, Florida

Stay Connected

Get resources, event updates, and community news delivered to your inbox.

📱 Add your number to receive text reminders for upcoming events. Standard SMS & data rates may apply.

State of the Nonprofit Community, Inc. is a 501(c)(3) organization. A COPY OF THE OFFICIAL REGISTRATION AND FINANCIAL INFORMATION MAY BE OBTAINED FROM THE DIVISION OF CONSUMER SERVICES BY CALLING TOLL-FREE, WITHIN THE STATE, 1-800-435-7352 (800-HELP-FLA), OR VISITING www.FloridaConsumerHelp.com. REGISTRATION DOES NOT IMPLY ENDORSEMENT, APPROVAL, OR RECOMMENDATION BY THE STATE. Florida Registration #CH43381

© 2026 State of the Nonprofit Community. All rights reserved.